Recent Comments
Recent Posts
  •          Tropical Oasis Thrives in Brentwood
  •          We’ve Covered A Lot In Three Years!
  •            Is Your Store Green ?
  • The Sentinel on Damelart
  • The Gift of Good Morning
  • Is CRD’s Sewage Plan the Solution?
  • How did this happen in our backyard?
  • Excellence and Environment at Elk Lake
  •        Harold Steves, the ‘father of the ALR’
  • Change The World – Nepal Is Next
Subscribe
Latest Poll

Do you support the use of human waste as fertilizer?

View Results

A Tale of Two Fire Halls

by Ed Johnson, Citizen Journalist

Peninsula residents have recently had the unique opportunity of watching two neighbouring municipalities both increase their fire protection, in very different ways.

The Saanich Peninsula will soon be home to two new fire halls once the Central Saanich Main Fire Hall reaches completion and opens its doors in September.

North Saanich just completed their renovation and celebrated with a grand opening last June, to a crowd of over 200 people.

With a 2,000 square foot addition to their main station on Wain Rd, the North Saanich Fire Department now has two new bays for their pumper truck, rescue truck and service vehicle. The original three bays were converted into offices, dispatch rooms and a boardroom.

A looming tower above the station serves as a training aid for lowering firefighters into tight locations and also provides an ideal place to dry hoses. “These hoses can run up to 800 dollars per roll, so we take real good care of them to avoid abrasion and mold,” says North Saanich Fire Chief Gary Wilton.

In addition to the main fire hall, North Saanich also has two pumpers located at a satellite station on McTavish Road, bringing the total square footage to just over 11,000 square feet for both facilities.

Our average time to arrive at the scene of a fire after the first call is eight minutes. It takes just three minutes for our volunteers to arrive at the station,” says Chief Wilton.

Advertiser


North Saanich financed their 1.68 Million dollar upgrade by way of referendum, with a voter approval rating of 73%.

Central Saanich on the other hand, chose a different approach when implementing their new fire hall.

At over 23,000 square feet, the new Central Saanich Main Fire Hall is the largest municipal fire hall in the Capital Regional District. Victoria has the second largest fire hall at 22,992 square feet and Saanich is third at 21,100 square feet.

With four double length bays, a training facility, a hose tower, a twenty seat boardroom and a playground – the new main fire hall on Keating X Road will serve the community’s needs for many years, says Central Saanich Fire Chief Ron French.

Central Saanich is one of two municipalities, Sidney being the other, that have a ladder truck capable of a 75 foot extension. Unique to Central Saanich is a water/foam vehicle used for rural areas without nearby hydrants.

In planning for over six years, “the total cost including land purchase is 8.9 Million” says Chief French.

However, when factoring in the borrowing costs over the 23 year period, the cost rises to over 13 million dollars, according to figures released by the District of Central Saanich.

Instead of a referendum, funding for this fire hall was obtained using the “Alternative Approval Process”, whereby borrowing is automatically approved, if less than 10% of Central Saanich voters sign a petition requiring a community wide referendum.

This District hopes to offset some costs with the sale of a Verling Avenue property and a Green Municipal Fund Grant. Both would total 3.5 million dollars if successful.

The CRD Hazmat team is stationed at the new hall and training sessions have already been scheduled for the Coast Guard and FortisBC. In November, a large gathering of the Vancouver Island Volunteer Fire Fighters’ Association will also take place. “Instead of sending our guys elsewhere for this training, we will be saving money and travel time using our facility instead” says Chief French.

He also suggests there is a possibility that home fire insurance rates may decrease when Fire Underwriters review the new building sometime next year, as it relates to improved response times.

The existing Central Saanich fire hall on Mt. Newton X Rd. will continue to serve as a satellite station and will also require renovation. The cost of upgrading the satellite station is included in the proposed 12 million dollar Town Hall project, which is still undetermined.

The satellite station, combined with the new main fire hall, will provide Central Saanich with approximately 30,000 square feet of fire hall infrastructure – nearly triple that of North Saanich.

With Mutual Aid Agreements in place, Sidney, Central Saanich and North Saanich fire departments have agreed to assist one another when necessary; resulting in five fire halls serving the peninsula.

So as the dust finally settles, and the construction pauses for the time being, each fire hall may serve as a lasting reminder of how two neighbouring communities can be so similar, yet so different – each one personified through bricks and mortar.

Share/Bookmark

6 Responses to “A Tale of Two Fire Halls”

  • Sue Stroud:

    Excellent story and well presented. I thought the glow in the dark fire hall picture was a real eye-catcher and the burned paper chart won’t be forgotten any time soon. You have to wonder why CS is so hell bent on building more than we need and burdening the future with debt. Was this the Alternate Approval Process that lost by only a few votes because the municipality wouldn’t extend the time frame to make up for the days lost to a postal lockout? I believe it is and there needs to be an appeal process for situations like that. Wouldn’t it be nice if our schools could get a playground by simply having themselves added into the expenses for the new municipal hall (it would sure save a lot of parents a lot of fundraising work!).

    Reply
  • Karla Sofen:

    The fire station is built and open. And Sue Stroud still wants a do over? Sue can run again and state her positions on the issues and solutions to the problems she sees. When she does, she’ll still get the least number of votes just like all the other times. Sue, your community disagrees with you. It’s okay to keep raising the same objections again and again, but at some point democracy has to mean something. An infinite number of elections and appeals and more and more roadblocks and more and more nimbyism on more and more proposals will eventually cause and encourage the opposite of everything you seem to want. I hope you will take a step back and re-consider how to accomplish goals. The first step is having goals of your own. Shattering and preventing everyone else’s goals and accomplishments with endless complaints and endless criticism is not a goal or accomplishment.

    Reply
    • Steve Ward:

      I hate to be pedantic, but the statement that Sue Stroud always gets the least number of votes in the elections is false. The election results for 2011 show that there were in fact three candidates with fewer votes than Stroud.

      Stroud had 1168 votes out of 4674 total votes cast, which is a hair below 25% of the votes cast. Although 25% of the votes seems like quite a minority, it’s worth noting that the median vote fraction for the elected councilors was only about 52%, and no elected councilor received more than 63% of the votes. The threshold for election was only 43% of the votes.

      Thus it would appear that the statement “your community disagrees with you” neglects a significant fraction of the voters in the community.

      As for the value of questioning the size and financing of a project that has almost been completed, the value would seem to be in highlighting any examples of poor judgement during that project, in the hope of avoiding similar poor judgement on upcoming large projects that are currently in the planning stage.

      Hopefully this information provides clearer context for the discussion.

      Reply
  • Central Saanich Resident:

    Karla, could you please be more specific, what is “everyone else’s goal”?

    Reply
    • Karla Sofen:

      To get what you want, you must first know what you want. Did the fire station simply materialize out of thin air? The goal was first thought of, and then achieved. Sue needs to come up with a tangible goal to achieve and then focus efforts to accomplish it. It’s just too easy to criticize and complain about the goals achieved by others. It’s not the critic that counts. It’s not the man who sits idly by and points out how the strong man stumbled that makes any difference in our community. And there it is. The fire station is there. It’s tangible. It’s been built and it’s open. What is to be accomplished by bemoaning about it now?

      I’m always amused by the peanut gallery here pretending not to understand my points so that they can rationalize their ill-considered positions and public statements and pretend how it can’t possibly apply to them. Ha!

      Reply
  • uucluelet:

    I think one should add an analysis of the Oak Bay Fire Hall renovations, which were adequate and far more financially responsible than Central Saanich’s.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Comments appearing in Saanich Voice Online are opinions of the writers and do not represent the official position of Saanich Voice Online. To be considered for publication, comments should be no more than 250 words. They may be condensed by Saanich Voice Online, although care is taken to preserve the core of the writer's comment. Saanich Voice Online may freely reproduce comments in print, electronic or other forms. In order to encourage open exchange of ideas Saanich Voice Online requests that all writers maintain mutual respect. Saanich Voice Online will endeavour to not publish unsubstantiated allegations, personal attacks or offensive language and reserves the right to decide whether or not to accept comments. Any letter that appears irrelevant will be submitted to the Editor-in-Chief and adviser for acceptance or rejection. Saanich Voice Online welcomes interest from those who wish to write stories as citizen journalists. We ask that you contact us by email so that we can share our guidelines for stories.

Advertisers
Green Earth
Celia Stock
Click for Video-MC
Yager
Devine Vineyards
Boat Show
Getz & Burden
Elizabeth May
Lifestyle Market
Investment Planning Counsel
McGinnis Electric
GH
Graphic FX Signworks
Saanich Physio
Kumon
Zeb King